What Tests Determine Whether Eyelid Surgery Is Medically Necessary?
- Posted on: Nov 15 2026

People in St. Louis, St. Peters, and Arnold, MO, turn to Ophthalmic Plastic and Cosmetic Surgery, Inc. for eyelid and orbital care. Our surgeons include John B. Holds, MD, FACS, a board-certified ophthalmologist who has practiced in St. Louis since 1990; Adam G. Buchanan, MD, also board-certified in ophthalmology and fellowship-trained in oculofacial plastic surgery; and Sara Reggie, MD, a board-certified ophthalmologist with advanced oculofacial training.
Visual Field Testing With and Without Lifted Eyelids
One of the clearest ways to document functional vision problems is a visual field test. You’ll look toward a fixed point while specialized equipment measures how much you can see above and around you. The test is often repeated with your upper lids gently taped or held up.
When the second test shows that lifting your eyelids opens a significant amount of your upper field of vision, that supports the case for functional surgery. This may help explain why driving, reading street signs, or looking upward feels more difficult than it used to.
Eyelid Measurements and Eye Health
Your surgeon checks where the upper eyelid sits relative to the pupil and examines excess skin around the lashes. One measurement, called margin reflex distance (MRD1), records the distance between the upper eyelid margin and the reflection of a light on your eye.
These measurements help distinguish sagging skin (dermatochalasis) from ptosis, which occurs when the upper eyelid margin droops because of problems with the muscles or nerves that control its position. That difference matters because functional upper lid blepharoplasty removes excess skin, while ptosis repair corrects the eyelid’s position. Sometimes both need attention.
A complete eye exam can also identify dry eyes or other conditions that affect surgical planning.
Photographs and Descriptions of Daily Symptoms
Medical photographs record how much tissue hangs over the eyelid margin or lashes, while your account of daily problems adds context. Tell us about needing to tilt your head back, raise your brows, or lift your eyelids to see clearly.
These details help connect the physical findings to what you’re experiencing.
Does Passing the Tests Mean Insurance Will Pay?
Not automatically. Insurance companies have different requirements for documenting medical necessity. Some specify a minimum degree of visual field impairment, while others also request photographs or additional examination findings.
Your surgeon’s evaluation, records of vision problems, and insurer’s criteria all matter. A cosmetic eyelid change that doesn’t interfere with function generally isn’t covered.
Find Out What’s Causing Your Eyelid Symptoms
Trouble seeing past your upper eyelids deserves more than a guess about insurance. Our surgeons at Ophthalmic Plastic and Cosmetic Surgery, Inc. can evaluate your eyelid function and discuss your options. To arrange an appointment in St. Louis, St. Peters, or Arnold, MO, contact us or call 314-567-3567.
Posted in: Eyelid Surgery
